✨ Tap FILTER / Shop by CATEGORY ✨

Newest items appear first.

Shop

Shop

Filters

Quick View
Pop Art Soft "Skelephant" Plush 2022
$10.99
Quick View
Charmander - 10" Pokémon Plush Toy
$13.99
Quick View
Ozzy Osbourne - Blizzard of Ozz (CD, Jet Records)
$14.99
Quick View
Crash Bandicoot - Jet Pack Crash Funko Pop! #273
$8.99
Quick View
Super Mario Wii Metal Lunchbox Tin (Red Question Block Design)
$3.99
Quick View
Ozzy Osbourne - Bark at the Moon (1983)
$24.99
Quick View
Conspiracy Survival Kit - For the Paranoid in your life!
$14.99
Quick View
Shadow House: You Can't Hide by Dan Poblocki (Hardcover)
$7.99
Quick View
Vintage Ozzy Osbourne - Speak of the Devil (1982)
$24.99
Quick View
Squishmallows Gordon the Shark with Goggles Plush
$10.99
Quick View
Squishmallows "Gordon the Shark"
$7.99
Quick View
Slammer Whammers Super Pro Bass Slammer with 4 Flash Caps (1990s)
$6.99
Quick View
POG KT-100 Official Tournament Game Pad (WPF World POG Federation, 1990s) - Blue
$9.99
Quick View
POG KT-100 Official Tournament Game Pad (WPF World POG Federation, 1994) - Red
$9.99
Quick View
Slammer Whammers Super Pro Bass Slammer with 4 Flash Caps (1990s)
$6.99
Quick View
Trivial Pursuit: Horror Ultimate Edition
$25.99
Quick View
Blockbuster Party Game
$9.99
Quick View
Hellraiser
$3.99
Quick View
Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman (Hardcover, 1995) First Edition / First Printing
$95.00
Quick View
Magic's Most Wanted by Tyler Whitesides (Hardcover, 2021)
$4.99
Quick View
Doorways to Horror: The VCR Game (Pressman, 1987)
$27.99
Quick View
Slammers 6-Pack -- Premium Collector Caps (American Game Caps, 1990s)
$6.99
Quick View
Deddy Bears "Frankenbear" Plush Coffin Edition (2003)
$9.99
Quick View
Z.E.O - A Zombie's Guide to Getting A(Head) in Business by Scott Kenemore (2009 Paperback)
$11.99
Quick View
Saw (2004) - Genuine Blockbuster Rental Copy (New Release 2-Day Rental)
$17.99
Quick View
The Skeleton Key (2005) - Reflective Slipcover Edition DVD
$11.99
Quick View
American Horror Story: The Complete First Season (Murder House) - 3 Disc DVD Set
$12.99
Quick View
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) - Authentic Blockbuster Rental Case ( 1-Week Rental Edition)
$18.99
Quick View
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (40th Anniversary Edition DVD - Sealed)
$13.99
Quick View
Killer Klowns from Outer Space (Midnite Movies DVD)
$5.99
Quick View
Devil in the Flesh (DVD 1998)
$3.99
Quick View
Resident Evil Trilogy (3-Movie DVD Box Set)
$6.99
Quick View
Jeepers Creepers
$4.99
Quick View
Halloween Unrated - Directors Cut
$3.99
Quick View
Jeepers Creepers 2
$4.99
Quick View
Team Rocket's Murkrow - Pokemon TCG (200/182) Scarlet & Violet:151 - Full Art Holo
$10.99
Quick View
Mew EX (205/165 SAR) - Japanese Pokémon TCG Scarlet & Violet 151
$199.99
Quick View
Trafalgar Law (Leader Card) One Piece Card Game OP01-002
$7.99
Quick View
Onix - 2023 Japanese Pokémon TCG Classic Holo (Venusaur & Lugia EX deck) - CGC 9 Mint
$8.99
Quick View
Yu-Gi-Oh! - The Dark Magicians (RA01-EN054) 1st Edition Quarter Century Stampede
$12.99
Quick View
Pokémon - Team Rocket's Mewtwo EX 081/182 Scarlet & Violet: 151
$4.99
Quick View
Prey - Feral Predator Ultimate Bear Blood Action Figure (NECA 2023) 9" Walmart Exclusive
$27.99
Quick View
ALF - Ultimate Action Figure (NECA 2023)
$24.99
Quick View
NECA Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles x Universal Monsters - Michelangelo as The Mummy (7-inch Ultimate Figure)
$34.99
Quick View
NECA Halloween Kills - Ultimate Michael Myers Action Figure (7" Collectible)
$40.00
Quick View
NECA Universal Monsters - Boris Karloff as The Mummy (Ultimate 7-inch Action Figure)
$27.99
Quick View
The Silence of the Lambs - Hannibal Lecter (NECA)
$26.99
Quick View
Frankenstein's Monster - Universal Monsters Collection (NECA)
$24.99
Quick View
Dracula (Ultimate Count Dracula) - NECA Universal Monsters
$34.99
Quick View
Scream: Ghostface - McFarlane Movie Maniacs Series 2 (1998)
$54.99
Quick View
Stranger Things x Masters of the Universe - Demogorgon vs. Skeletor Retro Play 2-Pack (Mattel)
$21.99
Quick View
Stranger Things x Masters of the Universe - Vecna vs. Heman Retro Play 2-Pack (Mattel)
$27.99
Quick View
Batman (McFarlane Collector Edition) - DC Multiverse
$20.99
Quick View
Fangoria Magazine #190 (2000) - Scream Cover - House on Haunted Hill, Pitch Black, & More!
$18.99
Quick View
Scumbug - Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Ultimates (Super7)
$49.99
Quick View
NECA Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles x Universal Monsters - April O'Neil as The Bride of Frankenstein
$29.99
Quick View
NECA Dungeons & Dragons: Zarak the Evil Half-Orc Assassin - Ultimate Action Figure
$35.99
Quick View
Leatherface - Funko Pops Keychain
$10.99
Quick View
Hannibal Lecter - Silence of the Lambs Keychain
$12.99
Quick View
Bandai Legacy Mighty Morphin Power Rangers - Pink Ranger 6.5" (Build-A-Megazord)
$13.99
Quick View
Bandai Legacy Mighty Morphin Power Rangers - Yellow Ranger 6.5" (Build-A-Megazord)
$17.99
Quick View
The Walking Dead #20 - First Print (Signed by Robert Kirkman, COA Included)
$125.00
Quick View
Squishmallows - Kristy the Butterfly (Small Plush)
$9.99
Quick View
DC Direct - Blackest Night Series 3: Black Lantern Aquaman (Sealed)
$29.99
Quick View
Hot Wheels Monster Trucks "Yoshi"
$18.99
Quick View
Hot Wheels Monster Trucks - Super Mario "Bowser"
$14.99
Quick View
Super Mario "Larry with Magic Wand" (Jakks Pacific)
$6.99
Quick View
Hot Wheels RacerVerse Jurassic World 4-Pack (Mattel 2023)
$15.99
Quick View
Funko POP! Movies - How to Train Your Dragon (3-Pack Bundle)
$59.99
Quick View
Anime Ghost Girl Figure - PVC Statue (with base, new in bag)
$29.99
Quick View
Banchee - Season 1 Pilot (2013 HBO - Cinemax Promotional DVD)
$5.99
Quick View
Heathers (1988) - Limited Edition Blu-ray Box Set
$67.99
Quick View
The Walking Dead #100 (2012) - Hyundai Undead Variant - Image Comics
$14.99
Quick View
Butterfly #1 (2014) Arachaia / BOOM! Studios - 1st Printing - Amazon TV Series
$64.99
Quick View
Beavis and Butt-head #1 (Marvel Comics, 1994)
$10.99
Quick View
Marvel Super Action #18 (1980) - Behold... The Vision! (Reprint Issue, Newsstand Edition)
$15.99
Quick View
3D Printed Horror Knife Display Set - Neon Green & Black (Set of 6)
$11.99
Quick View
Spider-Man - The Hobgoblin
$10.99
Quick View
Cats vs. Pickles - Black Cat Lagoon
$5.99
Quick View
Goosebumps VHS - The Haunted Mask II
$9.99
Quick View
Goosebumps VHS - The Haunted Mask
$9.99
Quick View
X-Men The Phoenix Saga
$32.99
Quick View
The Purge Blueray (Sealed)
$5.99
Quick View
Freddy vs. Jason
$4.99
Quick View
Funko Pop! Carrie (Bloody) #1247
$11.99
Quick View
Funko Pop! Comic Covers - Batman #05
$29.99
Quick View
"Waiting for Halloween" Metal Wall Sign - Horror Icons Coffee Design
$10.99
Quick View
Marvel Legends Series - Agatha Harkness (WandaVision) 6"
$23.99
Quick View
Dragon Ball Super Aura Energy Effect Display Base (PINK)
$11.99
Quick View
Dragon Ball Super Aura Energy Effect Display Base (BLUE)
$11.99
Quick View
Custom 3D Printed Jack Skellington Figure
$4.99
Quick View
Annabelle Horror Movie Silicone Keychain - 4"
$6.99
Quick View
Street Fighter II "Arcade Legends" Metal Sign
$9.99
Quick View
Spiderman - "City Swing" Metal Sign
$9.99
Quick View
"The Slasher Collective" Metal Sign
$11.99
Quick View
Spider-Dragon Fusion 16" 3D Print
$34.99
Quick View
Funko Pop! Comic Cover - Amazing Fantasy #15 Spider-Man (#05)
$23.99
Quick View
Friday the 13th - Jason Voorhees Foam Latex Mask - House of Horror
$34.99
Quick View
Banpresto ONE PIECE: Glitter & Glamours - NAMI
$44.99
Quick View
NECA Toony Terrors Halloween - Michael Myers (Front Porch)
$19.99
Quick View
NECA Toony Terrors - Michael Myers (Hospital Door)
$19.99
Quick View
Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice Wall Clock
$29.99
Quick View
Funko Pop! Marvel Studios What If...? - Zombie Hunter Spidey (#945)
$14.99
Quick View
Batman #163 (May 1964) - DC Comics
$210.00
Quick View
Vintage 1992 Ceramic Pumpking Luminaria Set
$22.99
Quick View
Pokémon Terrarium Collection Vol. 13 Re-Ment Miniature Figure Set
$7.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - GENGHIS FROG
$19.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Movie Star - Leonardo
$24.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Movie Star - Donatello
$23.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Movie Star - Mike
$24.99
Quick View
WWE Legends Line Elite Series - Chyna
$21.99
Quick View
The Client
$2.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Movie Star - Raphael
$23.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Movie Star - Super Shredder
$27.99
Quick View
Casper and Wendy Wonder Book (1963)
$5.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Leonardo Comic Book + Action Figure Set
$24.99
Quick View
Pokémon GO Dragonite VSTAR Premier Deck Holder Collection
$49.99
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - April O'Neil (1988)
$64.99
Quick View
Stranger Things x Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
$16.99 $19.99
Sale
Quick View
Super Mario - Cat Mario
$5.99
Quick View
Spooky Magic: The Floating Body (1969)
$4.99
Quick View
Super Mario - Fire Mario with Fireball
$6.99
Quick View
Spooky Tricks (1969)
$4.99
Quick View
Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982)
$300.00
Quick View
Halloween II (1981)
$275.00
Quick View
HALLOWEEN by Curtis Richards (1979)
$650.00
Quick View
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles "Movie Star" Splinter
$19.99
Quick View
Marvel Legends: Silk & Doc Ock
$69.99
Quick View
Marvel Legends: Spider-Shot
$17.99
Quick View
Marvel Legends Ultimate: Miles Morales
$18.99
Quick View
How to Train Your Dragon - Toothless and Light Fury
$6.99
Quick View
How to Master Video Games (1981)
$6.99
Quick View
The Complete Book of Ghosts
$6.99
Quick View
A Treasury of American Horror Stories
$13.99
Quick View
Poltergeists and Other Hauntings
$6.99
Quick View
Hocus Pocus & The All-New Sequel
$29.99
Quick View
Fantasy Annual III (Stephen King short story) (1981)
$29.99
Quick View
Some Bodies in the Attic: A Mini Spooky Pop-up Book
$15.99
Quick View
Darkness Creeping: Twenty Twisted Tales
$5.99
Quick View
Half-Witch
$9.99
Quick View
The Ghosts of Now
$2.49
Quick View
The Oxford Book of the Supernatural
$8.99
Quick View
Marvel Legends Retro Collection Spider-Man: Black Cat
$59.99
Quick View
Hasbro Marvel Legends Series: Spider-Man Maximum Venom - Ghost-Spider (BAF)
$21.99
Quick View
Ty Beanie Babies Official Club Platinum Edition Membership Kit
$29.99
Quick View
Universal Studios Classic Monster Collection - Dracula
$3.99
Quick View
Goosebumps Lot (First 3 books of the series) R.L. Stine
$17.99
Quick View
Jesse James Meets Frankenstein's Daughter
$4.99
Quick View
Scream Greats Series 1 - Michael Myers
$29.99 $49.99
Sale
Quick View
NECA Hatchet - Victor Crowley
$34.99 $49.99
Sale
Quick View
Squishmallows 10" Wicked Witch Plush - Wizard of Oz
$14.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Carrie - 1992
$14.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Children of the Corn
$13.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Cujo
$12.99
Quick View
Stephen King's IT
$9.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Pet Sematary
$19.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Misery
$9.99
Quick View
The Boogeyman (Stephen King's -Nightshift Collection, Volume 2)
$4.99
Quick View
Stephen King's Sometimes They Come Back
$3.99
Quick View
Three Bees Collectibles Gift Card - $10
$10.00
Quick View
Three Bees Collectibles Gift Card - $25
$25.00
Quick View
Three Bees Collectibles Gift Card- $50
$50.00
Quick View
Three Bees Collectibles Gift Card - $100
$100.00
Quick View
The Exorcist - 25th Anniversary Special Edition
$5.99
Quick View
The Silence of the Lambs
$3.99
Quick View
Young Frankenstein
$4.99
Quick View
R.L.Stine - Goosebumps: Monster Blood I, II & III Bundle
$22.99
Quick View
DC Universe Classics Sinestro Corps: Scarecrow
$23.99
Quick View
The X-Files: The Ultimate X-Perience (Limited Edition VHS, Sealed)
$10.99
Quick View
Ghostbusters GOZER (BAF)
$19.99
Quick View
Ghostbusters - Stay Puft Marshmallow Man - Light up Figure
$9.99
Sold Out
Quick View
Jakks Pacific - Super Mario Bros. Movie - TOAD
$5.99
Quick View
NECA - Gargoyles - Ultimate BRONX
$38.00
Quick View
NECA - E.T. & Elliott with Bicycle
$21.99 $42.99
Sale
Quick View
Vintage HALLOWEEN Black Cat & Pumpkin blow mold
$39.99
Quick View
NECA - Gargoyles - Ultimate THAILOG
$45.00
Quick View
World's Smallest / Micro Figures - EGYPTIAN MUMMY (Series 2)
$9.99
Quick View
World's Smallest / Micro Figures - THE FLY
$9.99
Quick View
World's Smallest - Micro Figures - THE WOLF MAN
$9.99
Quick View
NECA - Toony Terrors - M3GAN
$21.99
Quick View
Hauntings: True Stories of Unquiet Spirits
$4.99 $6.99
Sale
Quick View
NECA - Gargoyles - Ultimate DEMONA
$40.00
Quick View
1990's ALIEN POPS Lollipop Candy Counter Display
$89.99
Quick View
Noctilca: Resurrection of Monstress - Night of Witch
$54.99
Quick View
Twisted Myths: 20 Classic Stories with a Dark and Dangerous Heart
$7.99

No results found

No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.