✨ Tap FILTER to shop by CATEGORY ✨ Newest items appear first. Shop Shop Clear All | Featured Drops - Life is Strange | Collectors' Vault | Gift Cards | Action Figures - Display Pieces - Loose Toy | Seasonal & Holiday Collections | Witchcraft/Magic | DVD | VHS | Books | Comics | Trading Cards | Music Media - CD & Cassettes | Funko Pops | Plush/Dolls | 3D Prints & Stickers | Pokémon | Games & Misc Retro | Filters Categories All Featured Drops - Life is Strange Collectors' Vault Gift Cards Action Figures - Display Pieces - Loose Toy Seasonal & Holiday Collections Halloween Decor Witchcraft/Magic DVD VHS Books Goosebumps Comics KEYs Trading Cards Music Media - CD & Cassettes Funko Pops Plush/Dolls 3D Prints & Stickers Pokémon Games & Misc Retro Filter Clear Filter Quick View Mary Shelley's Frankenstein $2.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Planet Terror (2 Disc Special) $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Shining $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Punisher #1 Vol. 1 The King of Killers - Jesus Saiz Cover (2022) $8.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Cave $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - UNRATED $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Village $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Texas Chainsaw Massacre $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gremlins - Special Edition $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stigmata $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Hostel $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Amityville Horror $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Red Riding Hood $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View IT Chapter 2 $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Vampire's Suck $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stay $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Army of Darkness $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Sleepy Hollow $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Silent Hill $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Exorcist - The Beginning $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View House of the Dead $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Day of the Dead (Sealed) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Sweeney Todd $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Dreamworks Trolls Fuzzbert Happy Meal Toy (2016) - Sealed McDonald's $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View 30 Days of Night $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Cult of Chucky $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Seed of Chucky $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Seven $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View American Pie (The Threesome Pack) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Diary of the Dead $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Dracula $2.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Survival of the Dead $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Slaughter Tales $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Van Helsing $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Battle Royale $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Nintendo Super Mario Coin Tokens & Question Block Lot - Pawn Game Pieces $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Nintendo Super Mario Slot Machine Toy - Push Button Coin Block $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Return of the Living Dead - Part 2 $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View April Fool's Day $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View New Avengers #33 $239.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Spider-Woman #1 $109.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Tales of Suspense #84 (1966) $54.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Avengers: Beyond #1 CGC 9.8 - Variant Edition $33.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Wild Things 1998 (Sealed) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The French Chef with Julia Child - Sealed DVD Collection - PBS $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Earth Girls are Easy - Special Edition 1988 $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Edward Scissorhands (Sealed) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Archie - Wizard of Oz #1 Yellow Brick Road Homage $34.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Archie Betty & Veronica - Cursed Library Alpha #1 - Hocus Pocus Variant $19.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Punisher #5 (2022) - Marvel Comics - Parental Advisory Variant Cover $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Death of Venomverse #1D $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View TMNT vs. Street Fighter #2 (Variant Cover C) $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Strange Academy #1 Miles Morales - Marvel $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Swamp Thing #81 (DC Comics Holiday 1988) $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View X-Men 1963 First Issue REPRINT 1991 - Stan Lee $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View DC Multiverse - Death Metal Batcycle Bone Bike McFarlane $17.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Squishmallows Stranger Things - DEMOGORGON 3.5" Clip Plush Keychain (New with Tags) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View X-Men: The Phoenix Saga - Triple-Sized Finale! (1994) - Factory Sealed $34.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View X-Men: The Phoenix Saga - The Dark Shroud (1994) - Factory Sealed $44.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stranger Things - DEMOGORGON Statue $54.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stranger Things - EDDIE MUNSON Statue $43.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Goosebumps SlappyWorld - Revenge of the Invisible Boy (R.L. Stine, Scholastic) $2.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Collector - K.R. Alexander (Scholastic, Horror Paperback) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Creepers - Stage Fright by Edgar J. Hyde (Horror Chapter Book) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Creepers - The Gravedigger by Edgar J. Hyde (Horror Chapter Book) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Hunt for Magic: The Priestesses Nightmares $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Poltergeists and Other Hauntings - Rupert Matthews (2009 Edition) $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stephen King - The Dark Half (1990 First Signet Printing) $12.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stephen King - Different Seasons (1983 First Signet Printing) $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Christopher Pike - Remember Me 3: The Last Story $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Diane Hoh - The Invitation $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View R.L. Stine - Broken (Fear Street Super Chiller 1993) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View D.E. Athkins - Sister Dearest (1991) $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #2: A Ghastly Shade of Green (1996) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #5: The Locked Room (1996) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #8 - Terror on Troll Mountain (1996) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #10 - The Curse of the New Kid (1996) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #12 - The Secret of Fern Island (1996) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #15 - Pool Ghoul (1996) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #19: The Thing in Room 601 (1996) $15.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #22 - Lost in Dreamland (1996) $2.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #1 - The Enchanted Attic (1996) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #18 - Your Momma's a Werewolf (1996) $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #11 - Guess Who's Coming for Dinner? (1996) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #3 - Ghost Writer (1996) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gremlins Metal Lunchbox - Stripe & Gizmo - Tin Box Company 2022 $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gremlins 1984 Trading Card & Hallmark Bundle - Topps Cards + Vintage Greeting Card + Wrapper $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View 3D - Printed Articulated Dinosaur - Green & Purple $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Skylanders Swap Force - Scratch $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Batman: The Animated Series - Kenner 1993 Orange Suit Batman (3.5" figure) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel - Black Panther Mini Figure $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Batman: The Animated Series - Catwoman (1993 Kenner 3" figure) $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Spin Master "Bat-Tech Batman" 2021 $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Oroku Saki "Shredder" - 1988 Vintage Playmates TMNT $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends Cap-Wolf / Custom-Made $37.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Funko Pop! Marvel - Bullseye (#131) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gremlins (Gizmo-Style) - 3D Printed Figure $8.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Mysterio 5" Spider-Man Villain (Hasbro) $16.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stitch - 3D Printed Figure (Black & Blue 4") $8.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View 2012 Playmates Toys TMNT Dogpound $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Squishmallows - Bly the Fortune Teller Cat $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View BAF Marvel Legends Deadpool "X-Men Team Shirt" Hasbro $13.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Light Fury - 3D Print $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Night Fury - 3D Print $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Nightcap" $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Squishmallows - Chanel the Cinnamon Roll (Large Plush) $15.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Peeps - Pink Bunny $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends Deadpool - Legacy Collection (Hasbro) $27.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Hello Kitty KUROMI Skeleton Squishmallows - Sanrio Halloween Edition $12.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends - Groot (Thor: Love & Thunder) Build-A-Figure Korg Piece $16.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #6 - Haunting House (1996) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #23 - Night of the Goat Boy (1997) $12.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #9 - The Mystic's Spell (1996) $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Funko Bitty Pop! Bouquet - Wicked: ELPHABA & GLINDA (3 Piece set) $29.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Funko Pop! Marvel Zombies - Zombie She-Hulk #792 (Special Edition Sticker) $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends - Hela (Thor: Ragnarok) $16.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends - Hydra Soldier / Commando (Blue Variant) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View ONE PIECE - Sabo $16.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Vintage Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Super Shredder (1991 Playmates) $18.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Witch is in - Wooden Sign $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Old World Christmas Glass Ornament - Witch's Hat $16.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Oh for Peeps Sake - Easter Decor $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Easter Bunny - Pillow Covers (18x18) Set of 2 $15.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Halloween Mini Ornament Set - Witch Hat, Skull, Pumpkin & Ghost (Set of 12) $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stainless Steel Wiccan Alter Plate - Engraved Pentagram Ritual Dish (5.5") $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Marvel Legends - Deadpool in Slippers (Hasbro, Loose) $27.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Witch Statue - Black Resin - 11.8" $15.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Halloween Ornament Ball Set - 16 Piece Spooky Tree Decorations $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Wicca: A Guide for the Solitary Practitioner - Scott Cunningham $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Buckland's Complete Book of Witchcraft (Llewellyn's Practical Magick) $24.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View More Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View New Ghost Stories II - The Fiction Desk (2014) $8.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View New Ghost Stories - Volume Six (2013) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Witches - Roald Dahl (Puffin Books, 2013 Reissue) $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Stalker - Faye Kellerman (First Avon Books Printing, 2001) $4.49 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Have a Spooktacular Halloween Wooden Sign - Retro Pumpkin Wall/Table Decor $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Tarot Card Deck - 78 Card Divination Set with Velvet Pouch & Guidebook $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Little People Collector: Stranger Things "Scoops Ahoy" Ice Cream Parlor Set $29.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos - "Mumford" The Mummy with a Spider - Halloween Edition $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Mystic" $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View NECA E.T. 40th Anniverary - Ultimate Dress-Up E.T. $19.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View TY Beanie Baby - Merlin $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gizmo Plush - Gremlins (NECA) $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View TY Beanie Boos "Tricky" $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Witch Statue - Black Resin - 8" $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View April Fools by Richie Tankersley Cusick (1990 - First Scholastic Printing) $12.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #24 - The Ghosts of Devil's Marsh (1998, Paradise Press First Print) $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shivers #17: Ghosts of Camp Massacre by M.D. Spenser (1996 - Paradise Press First Edition) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Dean Koontz's Frankenstein: Dead and Alive (Book Three, 2009 First Printing) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Umbreon 059/131 Prismatic Evolutions $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Pokémon TCG - Peru Print - Espinel & Umbreon (Los Exploradores Series) Black Edition $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Pikachu - Scarlet & Violet 151 AR #173/165 (Japanese) $15.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Charlotte Pudding - Big Mom Pirates - One Piece Card Game (ST12-012) $94.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Build-A-Bear Workshop "Autumn Bear" 2007 $18.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Freeze" the Penguin Plush - Holiday Edition $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Misty" the Snowman Plush - Holiday Edition $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Cheer" the Penguin Plush - Holiday Edition $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Alpine" the Reindeer Plush - Holiday Edition 2016 $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ty Beanie Boos "Mac" the Mouse - Holiday Edition 2019 $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View SLEEPAWAY CAMP - VHS Reproduction: Fan-made $31.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Vintage NapcoWare Turkey Salt & Pepper Shakers $24.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Gum-Gum Devil Fruit (Gomu Gomu no Mi) - 3D Printed Display Prop - One Piece $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Monkey D. Luffy Perpetual Desk Calendar Figure $25.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Pop Art Soft "Angelphant" Plush $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Pop Art Soft "Gypsy" Plush $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Pop Art Soft "Skelephant" Plush 2022 $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Charmander - 10" Pokémon Plush Toy $13.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ozzy Osbourne - Blizzard of Ozz (CD, Jet Records) $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Crash Bandicoot - Jet Pack Crash Funko Pop! #273 $8.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Super Mario Wii Metal Lunchbox Tin (Red Question Block Design) $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Ozzy Osbourne - Bark at the Moon (1983) $24.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Conspiracy Survival Kit - For the Paranoid in your life! $14.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Shadow House: You Can't Hide by Dan Poblocki (Hardcover) $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Vintage Ozzy Osbourne - Speak of the Devil (1982) $24.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Squishmallows Gordon the Shark with Goggles Plush $10.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Squishmallows "Gordon the Shark" $7.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Slammer Whammers Super Pro Bass Slammer with 4 Flash Caps (1990s) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View POG KT-100 Official Tournament Game Pad (WPF World POG Federation, 1990s) - Blue $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View POG KT-100 Official Tournament Game Pad (WPF World POG Federation, 1994) - Red $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Slammer Whammers Super Pro Bass Slammer with 4 Flash Caps (1990s) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Trivial Pursuit: Horror Ultimate Edition $25.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Blockbuster Party Game $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Hellraiser $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman (Hardcover, 1995) First Edition / First Printing $95.00 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Magic's Most Wanted by Tyler Whitesides (Hardcover, 2021) $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Doorways to Horror: The VCR Game (Pressman, 1987) $27.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Slammers 6-Pack -- Premium Collector Caps (American Game Caps, 1990s) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Deddy Bears "Frankenbear" Plush Coffin Edition (2003) $9.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Z.E.O - A Zombie's Guide to Getting A(Head) in Business by Scott Kenemore (2009 Paperback) $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Saw (2004) - Genuine Blockbuster Rental Copy (New Release 2-Day Rental) $17.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Skeleton Key (2005) - Reflective Slipcover Edition DVD $11.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View American Horror Story: The Complete First Season (Murder House) - 3 Disc DVD Set $12.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) - Authentic Blockbuster Rental Case ( 1-Week Rental Edition) $18.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (40th Anniversary Edition DVD - Sealed) $13.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Killer Klowns from Outer Space (Midnite Movies DVD) $5.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Devil in the Flesh (DVD 1998) $3.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Resident Evil Trilogy (3-Movie DVD Box Set) $6.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Jeepers Creepers $4.99 Add To Cart Added! Quick View Halloween Unrated - Directors Cut $3.99 Add To Cart Added! No results found No results match your search. Try removing a few filters. Previous Next
